Eagle on 5 Exquisitely Updated Historic Manor in the Village; heated indoor pool + hot tub

  • Welcome to Eagle on 5...
    Welcome to Eagle on 5...
  • ...a fully renovated 1916 Estate in the heart of Old Town Pinehurst.
    ...a fully renovated 1916 Estate in the heart of Old Town Pinehurst.
  • You know you're in for some true Southern Hospitality as soon as you arrive.
    You know you're in for some true Southern Hospitality as soon as you arrive.
  • So many historic details will make you feel like you stepped back in time.  Yet.
    So many historic details will make you feel like you stepped back in time. Yet.
  • From the brand new true chef's kitchen...
    From the brand new true chef's kitchen...
  • ...to the formal dining room that seats 10...
    ...to the formal dining room that seats 10...
  • Every architectural detail has been restored and every modern amenity provided!
    Every architectural detail has been restored and every modern amenity provided!
  • Here you can enjoy quality time together while enjoying the rich history.
    Here you can enjoy quality time together while enjoying the rich history.
  • The master suite is a tour de force, walk-in closets, sitting area...
    The master suite is a tour de force, walk-in closets, sitting area...
  • ...an exquisite Master Bath with a beautifully restored, original clawfoot tub.
    ...an exquisite Master Bath with a beautifully restored, original clawfoot tub.
  • Enjoy a multi-generation game of Poker - fun for every age!
    Enjoy a multi-generation game of Poker - fun for every age!
  • This beautiful estate was designed by Lyman F. Size, over 6000 sq ft of luxury.
    This beautiful estate was designed by Lyman F. Size, over 6000 sq ft of luxury.
  • Enjoy a large grill connected to a dedicated gas line - never run out of gas!
    Enjoy a large grill connected to a dedicated gas line - never run out of gas!
  • This grand estate has many wings so let's take a tour.
    This grand estate has many wings so let's take a tour.
  • The  grill is conveniently located just outside the expansive gourmet kitchen.
    The grill is conveniently located just outside the expansive gourmet kitchen.
  • Satisfy all of your beverage needs at our wet bar with dual zone drink fridges.
    Satisfy all of your beverage needs at our wet bar with dual zone drink fridges.
  • Gather your large group in the eat in kitchen with seating for 4 at the table...
    Gather your large group in the eat in kitchen with seating for 4 at the table...
  • ...and seating for 8 at the island for a total of seating for 12 comfortably!
    ...and seating for 8 at the island for a total of seating for 12 comfortably!
  • Two dishwashers, 3 sinks and over 100 sq ft of granite counter space will make..
    Two dishwashers, 3 sinks and over 100 sq ft of granite counter space will make..
  • ...prepping, cooking and eating a real joy!
    ...prepping, cooking and eating a real joy!
  • Ask us about the private chefs that have cooked gourmet meals here.
    Ask us about the private chefs that have cooked gourmet meals here.
  • Formal dinner parties - for 10! - are where amazing memories are made...
    Formal dinner parties - for 10! - are where amazing memories are made...
  • ...and relish in the period antiques and ambience!
    ...and relish in the period antiques and ambience!
  • Two beautiful powder rooms are located between the dining and living rooms.
    Two beautiful powder rooms are located between the dining and living rooms.
  • Bask in the true Grand Foyer as you head for the Living Room...
    Bask in the true Grand Foyer as you head for the Living Room...
  • ...another gathering place where 9 can comfortably gather and connect.
    ...another gathering place where 9 can comfortably gather and connect.
  • The fun continues indoors with the ultimate Game Room...
    The fun continues indoors with the ultimate Game Room...
  • ...from Old School Bingo...
    ...from Old School Bingo...
  • ...to our new Infinity game table...
    ...to our new Infinity game table...
  • ...or a multi-generation game of Poker - fun for every age!
    ...or a multi-generation game of Poker - fun for every age!
  • Meanwhile in the other wing, you can enjoy a different kind of fun!
    Meanwhile in the other wing, you can enjoy a different kind of fun!
  • Your own full length pool, always 83 degrees, a full bathroom...
    Your own full length pool, always 83 degrees, a full bathroom...
  • ...and a cozy lounge area for every generation!
    ...and a cozy lounge area for every generation!
  • This space is perfectly between the hot tub outside and the formal living room.
    This space is perfectly between the hot tub outside and the formal living room.
  • Here you can unwind and enjoy quality time in discerning comfort!
    Here you can unwind and enjoy quality time in discerning comfort!
  • Make more memories enjoying Cornhole outside on the picturesque grounds.
    Make more memories enjoying Cornhole outside on the picturesque grounds.
  • This gracious, expansive home makes it easy for any group to stay...
    This gracious, expansive home makes it easy for any group to stay...
  • ...and find cozy nooks to relax and catch up.
    ...and find cozy nooks to relax and catch up.
  • Because who doesn't love a proper Southern Front Porch?!
    Because who doesn't love a proper Southern Front Porch?!
  • Bask in the true Grand Foyer as you head to the second floor....
    Bask in the true Grand Foyer as you head to the second floor....
  • ...every space offers the opportunity to soak in the unique art.
    ...every space offers the opportunity to soak in the unique art.
  • Our 2nd floor boasts 8 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, laundry, family room and library.
    Our 2nd floor boasts 8 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, laundry, family room and library.
  • The upstairs Family room offers an additional cozy place to gather and connect.
    The upstairs Family room offers an additional cozy place to gather and connect.
  • From the chic kitchenette with bar seating for 3...
    From the chic kitchenette with bar seating for 3...
  • ...to another fireplace and HDTV.  Perfect to gather any time of day.
    ...to another fireplace and HDTV. Perfect to gather any time of day.
  • From the family room enter a master suite like you have never seen before!
    From the family room enter a master suite like you have never seen before!
  • From the luxe king bed, your own TV to the private balcony....
    From the luxe king bed, your own TV to the private balcony....
  • ...where you can take in a stunning view of the property and relax.
    ...where you can take in a stunning view of the property and relax.
  • The master bathroom features stunning details including a double antique vanity,
    The master bathroom features stunning details including a double antique vanity,
  • marble tiling throughout,
    marble tiling throughout,
  • and an expansive shower with two waterfall shower heads.
    and an expansive shower with two waterfall shower heads.
  • The master suite is complete with a separate nursery for our tiniest of guests.
    The master suite is complete with a separate nursery for our tiniest of guests.
  • Outside the family room you'll discover this country romantic ensuite Bedroom.
    Outside the family room you'll discover this country romantic ensuite Bedroom.
  • Just outside the laundry there is an expansive King bedroom with connecting bath
    Just outside the laundry there is an expansive King bedroom with connecting bath
  • That connects our youth suite with Queen and TwinXL over Queen Bunk + trundle.
    That connects our youth suite with Queen and TwinXL over Queen Bunk + trundle.
  • Guest Rooms 5 and 6 with an exquisitely tiled full bath.
    Guest Rooms 5 and 6 with an exquisitely tiled full bath.
  • Guest bedrooms 7 and 8 with queen beds and a full bath.
    Guest bedrooms 7 and 8 with queen beds and a full bath.
  • Guest 5 features a large TV and an antique desk...
    Guest 5 features a large TV and an antique desk...
  • ...that can also be used as a vanity.
    ...that can also be used as a vanity.
  • The library is the classic cozy spot for a tete a tete.
    The library is the classic cozy spot for a tete a tete.
  •  or maybe a one on one with your favorite book!
    or maybe a one on one with your favorite book!
  • This gracious, expansive home makes it easy for any group to stay...
    This gracious, expansive home makes it easy for any group to stay...
  • ...with 8 luxuriously comfortable bedrooms!
    ...with 8 luxuriously comfortable bedrooms!
  • This estate offers so many places to enjoy and explore....
    This estate offers so many places to enjoy and explore....
  • ...we know you'll all be comfortable and hope you enjoy our home!
    ...we know you'll all be comfortable and hope you enjoy our home!
  • There are also so many places to explore outside of the Cotton Cottage...
    There are also so many places to explore outside of the Cotton Cottage...
  • Start with visiting the Village Arboretum or Sandhills Horticultural Gardens!
    Start with visiting the Village Arboretum or Sandhills Horticultural Gardens!
  • And give younger guests the royal treatment at the Camelot playground!
    And give younger guests the royal treatment at the Camelot playground!
  • The classic Pinehurst experience is a visit to watch harness racing!
    The classic Pinehurst experience is a visit to watch harness racing!
  • And for a different kind of equine experience, visit the Aloha Safari.
    And for a different kind of equine experience, visit the Aloha Safari.
  • Grab a bite or a brew at one of our favorites, like the Pinehurst Brewery!
    Grab a bite or a brew at one of our favorites, like the Pinehurst Brewery!
  • The Village is a five-minute walk, and the Resort is literally down the road!
    The Village is a five-minute walk, and the Resort is literally down the road!
  • You really can experience it all at Eagle on 5!
    You really can experience it all at Eagle on 5!
  • And as you know, most come and stay with us to enjoy the golf!
    And as you know, most come and stay with us to enjoy the golf!
$788-15,888/night
8 Bedrooms • 7 Baths (6 full, 1 half) • Sleeps 10-18
Allows pets Internet Fireplace Private Pool (more...)

"There was something to do for every member in our household ranging from 19-87 years of age." ~ Mary

Imagined by Lymon F. Sise, the architect who designed the Pinehurst Resort and the Fair Barn, and originally built in 1916, Eagle on 5 (formerly known as Cotton Cottage) is like taking a step back into a more genteel time. When you enter the foyer from the front porch, you’ll immediately feel a sense of tranquility. Our premier property is located in the heart of the charming village of Pinehurst, NC, and guests have are steps away from boutiques, eateries, and the Resort.

Eagle on 5 was recently renovated in 2021 to restore and highlight the period craftsmanship throughout the home, while providing luxury updates that our discerning guests look for. Perfect for multi-generational families, we offer 8 spacious bedrooms, and 6 full baths.

"The house is a wonderfully remodeled historic manor. " ~ Barry

LIVING AREAS:

Graced with multiple living areas, guests can always find a spot that perfectly suits their mood. The main Living room boasts leather furnishings, complemented by gleaming hardwood floors, classic wainscoting and decor. An HDTV with WiFi is perfect for unwinding at the end of the day with friends and family. Keep a fire burning in the fireplace for a relaxed atmosphere.

Just off the Living room is the Game room, with a luxe 6-person poker table for hands-on competition, as well as an Infinity game table for the digital enthusiasts.

An upstairs library offers a cozy space to curl up in one of two side chairs and peruse one of the many titles on the shelves.

The second level also has a comfortable Family room complete with Kitchenette, boasting another designerleather sofa, HDTV, and a fireplace for ambiance.

We’ve added 7 brand new large Samsung Smart TVs throughout the home. Three are in the common rooms, with the 4 in the main bedrooms. They all have Spectrum Gold Live TV and streaming services. We also have Spectrum Gig Internet with an expansive Orbi mesh network for superior service throughout the home.

"Being a bit of a stickler about cleanliness, the house did not leave us disappointed. It was immaculate!!!! " ~ Daniel

Please note: We will consider up to 2 well-behaved, house-trained dogs for an additional refundable fee of $200. Tell us about your dog(s) and let’s decide together if he/she is a good fit for our home. We’re sorry that we’re unable to allow cats.

KITCHEN & DINING:

The Kitchen recently underwent an extensive renovation and has become a true chef’s domain, with a 48'' gas stove, 3 sinks, 2 dishwashers, a dual-zone beverage refrigerator, and a separate coffee station area that’s also easily set up as the perfect cocktail bar!

The large peninsula bar in the Kitchen seats 8, while the adjacent breakfast table seats an additional 4. In the formal dining room, you’ll find a large table for 10. Wherever you decide to enjoy your meal, you’ll no doubt be savoring a delicious meal.

"We would love to use this space for a large multi-family gathering in the future because there will be space perfect for everyone." – Jacob

If homecooking is not in your itinerary, please contact your host Beata about Chef Kelly of Pinehurst, who is always available to make a house call and create a magnificent meal!

BEDROOMS & BATHS:

Eagle on 5 has 8 bedrooms, 6 full baths, and 2 half baths, and can comfortably accommodate a total of 20 people. All bedrooms are on the second floor and feature new luxury mattresses.

Primary Bedroom Suite 1: King Bed and private ensuite bath with dual walk-in shower and restored cast iron clawfoot tub, original to the home.

Primary Bedroom Suite 2: Queen Bed with ensuite bathroom.

Guest Room 3: King bed with access to a Jack and Jill bath

Guest Room 4: Queen bed, plus a custom-built bunk with Twin XL over a Queen that also includes twin XL trundle. Shares the Jack and Jill bath with Guest Room 3.

Guest Room 5: King bed, shares hall bath with Guest Room 6

Guest Room 6: King Bed, shares hall bath with Guest Room 5

Guest Room 7: Queen Bed, shares hall bath with Guest Room 8

Guest Room 8: Queen Bed, shares hall bath with Guest Room 7

Guest Rooms 7 and 8 have their own separate staircase!

For our youngest guests, the room off the Master features a full-size crib and changing table with a new organic mattress and sheets.

Both half baths are on the first floor, and the full bath is adjacent to the indoor Pool area.

OUTDOOR AMENITIES:

Eagle on 5 offers a number of amenities that are sure to please all our guests.

Although it’s not outside, one of the favorite guest amenities is our indoor pool, heated year-round to a balmy 83°. There’s also a full bath and comfy lounge area – which means this space is always a hit!

We’ve recently installed a Viking hot tub for 8, perfect for the soothing evening soak, after a long day of golf or exploring the area.

And it’s easy to enjoy an al fresco family picnic for 6 with a large BBQ Grill, that has it’s very own dedicated gas line!

If you’re not at the Grill, try your hand at our Corn hole game while you’re waiting for dinner!

PLEASE NOTE: No smoking or vaping. Minimum age to rent is 30. Our property is considered part of the Village of Pinehurst so Guests are kindly reminded that quiet hours are from 10pm – 7am, and we ask that this courtesy is respected.

Pinehurst offers a charming, small-town atmosphere, complete with Southern hospitality. Those interested in Equestrian activities and Golf will find this area particularly engaging.

And there is plenty more to love about Pinehurst: shopping, antiquing, or best yet, a day at the Pinehurst Resort Spa! The wide variety of restaurants available is enough to satisfy any palate. Some of our particular favorites are the Pine Scone Cafe, the Agora Bakery & Cafe, the Pinehurst Brewery, Drum & Quill Pub, Lisi Italian restaurant.

Some of our favorite things to do in the area include The Village Arboretum and the Sandhills Horticultural Gardens, Rassie Wicker Park and the Camelot Playground, Harness Racing at the Fair Barn, the Aloha Safari, and of course, the Pinehurst Village, the Resort and the Spa.

Property Type House
House Rules
  • Maximum occupancy: 20
  • Children welcome
  • Pets considered
  • Smoking not allowed
  • Limited accessibility
  • Minimum age of primary renter: 30
Setting & View
  • Village
General
  • Internet
  • Fireplace
  • Central Heating
  • Linens Provided
  • Towels Provided
  • Washing Machine
  • Clothes Dryer
  • Private Living Room
  • Hair Dryer
  • Iron & Board
  • Safe
  • Basic Soaps
  • Paper Towels
  • Shampoo
  • Toilet Paper
Kitchen
  • Kitchen
  • Stove
  • Oven
  • Microwave
  • Dishwasher
  • Dishes & Utensils
  • Spices/Pantry Items
  • Coffee Maker
  • Toaster
  • Ice Maker
  • Blender
  • Kettle
  • Coffee Grinder
  • Kitchenette
  • Mini Fridge
Dining
  • Child's Highchair
Bathrooms 7 Baths (6 full, 1 half)
  • Bathroom 1 – Shower, Toilet, Tub
  • Bathroom 2 – Shower, Toilet
  • Bathroom 3 – Shower, Toilet
  • Bathroom 4 – Shower, Toilet
  • Bathroom 5 – Shower, Toilet
  • Bathroom 6 – Shower, Toilet
  • Bathroom 7 – Toilet
Sleeping Arrangements 8 Bedrooms, sleeps 10-18
  • Bedroom 1 – 1 King bed
  • Bedroom 2 – 1 Queen bed
  • Bedroom 3 – 1 Queen bed
  • Bedroom 4 – 1 Queen bed
  • Bedroom 5 – 1 King bed
  • Bedroom 6 – 1 King bed
  • Bedroom 7 – 1 Queen bed, 1 Bunk Bed
  • Bedroom 8 – 1 King bed
Entertainment
  • Satellite/Cable
  • Games/Board Games
  • Books
  • Toys
  • Game Room
  • Foosball
  • Smart TV
Family
  • Baby Gate
  • Pack N Play/Travel Crib
Outdoor
  • Outdoor Grill
  • Deck/Patio (uncovered)
  • Balcony/Terrace
  • Lawn/Garden
  • Walkable to Golf
  • Veranda
Pool/Spa
  • Private Pool
  • Indoor Pool
  • Heated Pool
Vehicles
  • Parking
Theme
  • Family
  • Historic
  • Romantic
Attractions
  • Health/Beauty Spa
Leisure
  • Antiquing
  • Bird Watching
  • Horseback Riding
  • Shopping
  • Wildlife Viewing
Sports & Adventure
  • Golf
Safety
  • Carbon Monoxide Detector
  • Deadbolt Lock
  • Fire Extinguisher
  • First Aid Kit
  • Exterior Lighting
  • Smoke Detector
  • Enhanced Cleaning Practices
  • Cleaning Disinfection
  • Common Surface Disinfectant Cleaned
  • Linens High Temp Wash
Season Rate
Default
1/1 - 12/31
Night
$688 - $1,988